Downtown Parking Garage Project Information
At their September 17 meeting, the Biddeford City Council voted to authorize the City Manager to enter into a Joint Development Agreement (JDA) with Treadwell Franklin Infrastructure Capital and James W. Sewall Company (“TFIC Sewall”) to build a downtown parking garage as well as complete the next phase the City’s RiverWalk. The JDA will outline the project design, costs, cost sharing provisions, revenue projections, support payments, and specific protections for the City. The City Council will review the JDA at a workshop on Tuesday, November 12 at 5:30 p.m. in the Council Chambers. You can view the agenda packet for that meeting here.
The purpose of this project is to reduce the property tax burden for residents and provide parking for current and planned development in the downtown and Mill District. No property tax dollars will be used to pay for this project, and the tax rate will not increase due to this project.
TFIC Sewall will design, build, and manage the parking garage. The City will contribute to the project through two sources. The first is through annual payments from the City’s TIF. Money in the TIF fund comes from sheltered property tax payments from businesses and developments in the Mill District – NOT from residential property taxpayers. The second source is revenues from the parking garage and parking lots. If parking revenues are less than expected, the City can make up the difference by collecting payments from surrounding properties in the Mill District, adjusting parking rates, or a combination of the two. If revenues are more than expected, the City will receive the benefit.
All on-street parking will remain FREE. During construction of the garage, rates for parking in surface lots will not increase. Once the garage is completed, rates for parking in the structure will be the same as surface lots. TFIC Sewall will also assume management of surface lots in the downtown area.
A parking garage is important to our community to promote continued downtown and Mill District development. This matters to taxpayers because new development makes buildings and properties more valuable. More valuable buildings pay more property taxes to the City, which helps stabilize the property tax rate. The construction of the garage is expected to provide the City of Biddeford an additional $16,407,604 in property taxes in the first 10 years of operation and a benefit of $39,772,744 over the 25 year lifetime of the agreement.
- What are the highlights of the approved project?
- How does a parking garage help property taxpayers?
- How will the garage be paid for? Will residential property tax dollars be used?
- Will this agreement affect on-street parking?
- How much will the parking garage cost to build?
- How were the revenue projections calculated? What happens if the garage doesn't generate as much revenue as expected?
- What happens if the garage generates more revenue than projected?
- What will it be like to park in the garage?
- What happens to the surface lot parking permit program if the City enters into this agreement?
- Who will handle operations, maintenance and enforcement?
- Who will pay for management of the garage?
- How will the Riverwalk expand as part of the project? Why is it included in this project?
- What happens at the end of the agreement?
- Who is included in TFIC Sewall's project team?
- Why was the 3 Lincoln Street site selected for this project?
- Has the downtown area lost any parking spaces due to recent construction projects or streetscape improvements?
- How will the traffic impacts of a parking garage in this location be addressed?
- Does the $15,000,000 listed for a parking garage in the TIF agreement determine the amount of money that can be used to fund payments for a parking garage?
- How did the closure of the Maine Energy Recovery Company impact the City's tax base?
- What has been the total tax commitment change since the closure of MERC?
- What does it mean when you say that there is nearly $40 million in new value that will be generated by the garage over time?
Parking Garage Finance Summary
The City prepared a project finance summary for the project. Parking Garage Finance Summary Through Year 10 lists the various line items associated with city contributions, property values, and tax revenue impacts with and without a garage. The impact a proposed garage will have on property values with a garage (row 16) and without a garage (row 17) is significant. At the end of ten years the difference in property value is anticipated to be upwards of $132 million dollars (row 18). The tax revenue generated over that same period is projected to be $16.4 million (row 23). It should also be noted that no property tax support is required (row 3).
Parking Demand Projections
According to DESMAN’s methodology for the parking study, the weekday demand for parking during peak periods is expected to exceed the capacity of the proposed 640-space garage. Upcoming developments in the area surrounding the parking garage are expected to need 893 total parking spaces during weekday peak demand periods – 60 spaces for customers and visitors, 695 shared spaces for employees and residents, and 138 reserved spaces for residents. DESMAN has concluded that if developments that have been announced move forward as anticipated, the proposed parking structure “will capture enough parking demand on typical weekdays to completely fill the facility, leaving no excess capacity to accommodate any future demand generated by surrounding land uses; in reality, some of the demand generated by the development will need to be accommodated off-site.”
On weekends, peak demand is projected to drop to 553 spaces – 82 for customers and visitors, 333 for employees and residents, and 138 reserved spaces for residents. (The decrease in demand on the weekend is due to the fact that a majority of office workers will not be on-site.) On the weekend, the projected peak demand for 610 spaces from the new development and the displaced existing demand can be accommodated by the proposed garage, while leaving a small number of spaces available to capture outside parking demand.
The table below shows the assumed users of the garage and the expected yearly revenues for the first 10 years that the garage will be in operation.
Upcoming Downtown Projects
The Biddeford City Council has approved a proposal for an ADA Access and Easement Agreement and Credit Enhancement with Riverdam, LLC. The proposed mixed-use project includes 13,300 square feet of commercial space, as well as 70 units of housing. Ten percent of those housing units will be restricted for the next 20 years as affordable housing. Per the agreement, the City will receive permanent easements to the land between the Riverdam building and the river wall to expand the RiverWalk, as well as permanent ADA access for the RiverWalk via the building’s elevators. The RiverWalk project, which will open up public access to the river and provide necessary pedestrian connections through the downtown, is reliant on these easements in order to move forward. A conceptual rendering of the proposed project is included below. For more information about this project, please click here.
The City of Biddeford has entered into a Master Plan Agreement with BE Fitler, LLC for the development of the City-owned property at 3 Lincoln Street. The Master Plan Agreement establishes two development sites at 3 Lincoln Street on both sides of the space reserved for the proposed parking garage. The developers, Jim Brady and Brian Eng, will seek to incorporate a mixture of residential, retail, office, hospitality, education and service uses with the proposed parking structure, RiverWalk, and riverside park to create an economically vibrant, urban-style mixed use destination. Known Biddeford entities have already expressed strong interest for a total of 80,000 square feet of commercial space in the first building. Additional details about the project are included in this press release.
LHL will redevelop the former Lincoln Mill site into a boutique hotel with amenities and market rate rental apartments. The project will include at least 90 high-end market rate apartments, a boutique hotel with amenities, and commercial space designed for a restaurant and bar, fitness center, rooftop pool, office use, and other commercial uses. LHL is expected to invest over $40 million in order to complete the project as approved.
- Watch the City Manager's presentation on the proposal at the August 27 City Council Workshop.
- Original Proposal from TFIC Sewall (as of June 30, 2019)
- TFIC Sewall Project Team
- Presentation from September 10 City Council Workshop
- September 18 Press Release announcing approval of project